Josh T-Mobile advert

There really are some awful PR pitches out there, with the rush to utilise aspects of social media into ad campaigns resulting in some pretty horrible creations.

And this. This is the Daddy of them all. I don’t really think that many PRs or journos or marketers really understand social media, or at least how best to utilise it. This is a perfect illustration.

The power of social media is in creating something of value that has the potential to zip around the web across multiple platforms. If you do this well then members of Joe Public will do the work for you.

I don’t have any inside information, but I’m willing to bet that CompareTheMarket.com has done pretty bloody well out of the CompareTheMeerkat.com campaign. It’s captured imaginations, is fluffy and potentially amusing. It’s perfect for social media platforms.

These Josh T-Mobile ads have not, because its fundamentally a pretty uninspired idea that smacks of lots of other bits and bobs out there at the moment.

‘Create a band by roaming around the country holding jamming sessions with oddballs’ is a cracking pitch only in the mind of an ad exec (and are all of those people on the bus really Josh fans, rather than paid-for actors and musicians?).

And if it were to ever take off it would only be due to the magnetic personality and shimmering talent of the individual fronting it.

Josh is not this person and, while probably a decent chap, cannot carry a massive multi-platform campaign on his thin, backpacking-around-India-during-a-gap-year shoulders and weedy one world wifflings.

Chuck in some awkward elements where Josh is required to suck some corporate cock in the form of some ill-fitting soundbites about how great T-Mobile is and the final nail in the coffin is hammered home.

I’ve said before that I don’t object in principle to stuff like this, but when it’s backed by a massive corporate outfit it’s never possible to see past the real reason it exists in the first place.

And that’s enough to turn it from something twee and rather nauseating into something genuinely awful.

Bizarre Carly Fiorina Sheep Attack Advert

OK, first up Carly Fiorina is the former CEO of Hewlett-Packard currently in the middle of a Senate run in California. Fiorina is gunning for the Republican nomination, after former employer HP booted her out in 2005 (to give you an idea of what they thought of her, HP has has since contributed to her opponent’s campaign fund).

So, you might think this ad is aimed at veteran Democrat Barbara Boxer. Nope, that’s not how US politics works. To first secure the Republican nomination Fiorina has to smear overcome other Republicans also seeking the nomination. So, this ad is aimed at fellow Republican Tom Campbell. Fiorina hasn’t even got to Boxer yet.

It’s so hard to know where to start with this ad. UK readers may be shocked by how vicious the ad is, especially considering its aimed at someone from the same political party. But low blows and negative campaigning are par for the course in US politics, especially from the right-wing, following Karl Rove’s foray into political campaigning.

What is more obvious is that this is completely swivel-eyed, wing-nut, bible-bashing, lib’rul-hatin’ batshit crazy, particularly odd in the relatively-liberal California. I mean, there’s a guy dressed up as a wolf in sheep’s clothing running around a hillside with glowing red eyes.

There’s a sheep standing on a doric column that starts ascending into the stratosphere as if animated by Terry Gilliam on an off day. There’s a bizarre attempt at an acronym that doesn’t even work – FCINO. And what do ‘Piety’ and Purity’ have to do with anything?

It’s a confused message, but is the message even important? To American’s perpetually scared, perpetually angry, perpetually suspicious right-wing populus it may successfully brand Campbell as evil, demonic or, even worse, a Fiscal Conservative In Name Only.

It’s a strategy that bombed with the UK’s rather less terrified population with the Tories’ Demon Eyes billboard poster in ’97, but the publicity it has garnered speaks for itself.

It’s often said that if you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it – and that’s a mantra the US right has run with, which is why plenty of people believed Obama was a communist, a Muslim, a homosexual or not even a US national during the 2008 campaign.

This ad takes that theory and turns it all up to 11. It’s all hyperbole, innuendo and flat-out smear. Already media outlets are declaring that this advert is so bonkers that it will finish off Fiorina’s campaign.

I hope they don’t underestimate just how susceptible US voters are to this kind of drivel. The fact that the seat in question is California offers some hope, but try telling Michael Dukakis that negative campaigning doesn’t work.

NB. Skip to 2.30 for the madness to begin.