Social media marketing versus print

Do you Facebook? Flickr? Youtube? Twitter? If so, you’ve probably been invited to become of fan of something utterly shit. Coke, the BMW X5 or Cillit Bang, something like that.

Why would you become a fan of such brands, or follow them on Twitter, or view a Youtube video of the making of the Duffy Coke ad ? If you had half a brain rattling around in your headspace, you wouldn’t, but marketers and advertisers think you do.

And there’s a whole host of social media evangelists, gurus and other assorted charlatans out there ready to convince you that you can sell more spam if only you were to have a Twitter account tweeting out spam recipes and spam-related news.

Here’s an experiment. Tweet a few remarks about Ford. You’ll almost certainly be followed by a few accounts that have something to do with selling cars. This is how the majority of people think social media works, even people within social media.

I’m not a naysayer about social media marketing, but I believe it’s hardly ever done properly. What’s more, I believe the opportunities for a successful social media campaign are few and far between, unless you have a huge amount of cash to wield.

On the flip side, I’ve seen the drop off in print and online media spend – so I’m aware of the limitations in many forms of marketing. TV seems to be reasonably bullet-proof, but the ROI of print and online seems to be on the way down.

I think online ads will get smarter, more targeted and more valuable. But I’m a bit uncertain about print. People are steadily moving away from print, which means less ad revenues, which means fewer journos, which means lower-quality content, which means fewer readers, which means lower ad revenues…

And I think social media campaigns will get better. Right now, most of them are about as subtle as printing a full-size ad in a newspaper that says ‘Drink Coke’. The fault lies in the campaigns, not the platform. Print has the opposite problem.

As social media becomes more sophisticated, it will get much better. And it will. You only have to look at the latest social platforms rolling out across the web like the Wehrmacht to see where the future lies.

So, while I think this ad for a newspaper ad sales department is amusingly accurate in skewering hyped-up social media campaigns, it’s worth remembering that it’s still an advert.

John Barnes rap Mars Bar Keith Allen terror

If you’re anything like me you’ll often find yourself wondering if you’re the only one. Y’know, the only person who doesn’t like Heroes, Porsche 911s, Magners or Justin Bieber (I’ve yet to find out what the latter actually is).

A few of my own pet, and it seems rather individual, peeves are coming together in the shape of a John Barnes rap for Mars, in time for the 2010 World Cup.

I like football, but recoil at the absurd pageantry, hyperbole and jingoism that goes with it. I find the absolute obsession many have with football perplexing and vaguely irritating.

We will be made to believe over the next four months that football is the most important thing in the world, and we wouldn’t have terrorism if only everyone just had a bloody big game of footy.

Bollocks. Football is one of the most obvious tools for, and reflections of, capitalism in all its dubious glory. All of this, of course, will reach its apotheosis this Summer.

Second in my list is New Order. I think they’re pretty awful, as it goes. This perplexes me and most of my friends, as I love electronic music, new wave, pop – every imaginable genre New Order could be said to belong to. Barring a handful of songs, I can’t even listen to them. It could be Bernard Sumner’s voice.

Thirdly, I hate the middle-class fetishisation of football that really hit its stride in the 90s with Keith Fucking Allen popping up on television every five fucking minutes, looking like a masturbating monkey and telling us he was mates with Gazza. People like Alex James, Damien Hurst and Matt Lucas used to join in. Everyone else seems to think it’s hilarious.

Footy songs are the most obvious product of this middle-class football wankery. None of them are any good. And Don’t throw World In Motion or that Echo and the Bunnymen one at me – they’re shit too. The only half-decent one is England’s Irie, but that’s only because it’s not really about football.

Apparently, John Barnes’ rap in the middle of World In Motion is the funniest thing that ever happened in the history of the world. When I think about it I can just imagine a hundred shit radio DJs getting their posse to recreate it. I can’t stand John Barnes.

More prosaically I hate adverts, branding, idents, corporate shite, marketing. But you knew that already.

All of which means this news about a new song for the World Cup featuring John Barnes performing an updated World In Motion rap that contains references to Mars bars in it does not please me.

Twenty years after John Barnes became an unlikely rapper in the official song for England’s 1990 football World Cup campaign, Mars has signed the former international to reprise his cringeworthy World In Motion turn in a TV ad campaign, MediaGuardian can reveal.

Barnes will feature in a re-recording of New Order’s World In Motion for a new Mars TV campaign launching late next month. Mars is also launching a competition to give members of the public the chance to appear in the ad.

Apparently the line ‘Three lions on our Mars’ will be inserted into the rap. By US-based behemoth Mars. No doubt Keith Allen will be twatting around in the background again. I can’t wait.