Bedtime stories – ActonCO2 advert

The rise of the internet has seen an accompanying rise in a bizarre kind of paranoid distrust of any kind of authority, especially those that might threaten people’s notions of individual liberty or rapacious appetites.

Fanned by the right-wing press and lunatic bloggers, there are now significant swathes of otherwise intelligent people who don’t believe in anthropological climate change, evolution, or any case for abortion.

All share an almost anti-Enlightenment rejection of scientific fact, based, as they are, on ideological principles rather than scientific ones.

The internet is largely to blame for this, and it has been adopted by right-wing groups as the principal method of dissemination of propaganda, smear tactics and outright lies – often slyly funded by vested interests.

These groups stoke up fires of ignorance and prejudice, which play straight into the hands of climate change sceptics, evolution deniers and the vast swathes of people who think governments are out to get/cheat/eat them.

We though the internet would become a tool for change, education and progression. Instead it’s become just the opposite – possibly the best tool for controlling the masses there has ever been.

It’s in this climate – no pun intended – that the government is attempting to encourage people to scale back their personal CO2 emissions, primarily by using the car and central heating less.

The ActonCO2 campaign is, to my mind, an effort to inspire a kind of blitz spirit among Britons – trying to get people to ‘do their bit’ in lowering emissions and fuel use.

But I don’t think it will work. The adverts are too negative, too gloomy and even vaguely threatening.

I think there is a rump of people in the UK who are willing to be persuaded on climate change but are subject to a constant drip-drip of denial and scepticism from media and a bizarre rogues gallery of people like Clarkson, Nigel Havers and David Bellamy.

But these ads won’t convince them. Even worse, they may scare them into a kind of sceptical defiance. How to do you get someone to buy into a product when they don’t think there’s any reason to buy it?

That’s the issue these adverts should be addressing. This Bedtime Stories advert is the first to make explicit the connection between human activity and climate change – it should be focussed on getting people to buy into that fact.

Because, as any advertiser will tell you, consumers need a reason to buy. These ActonCO2 ads are pushing a product before providing a reason to buy.

I think it can only end badly. Already this ad has attracted hundreds of complaints. And the forces of ignorance will seize on the ad as more grist to their anti-government, anti-science mill.

Is there a happy ending? Nope. Let’s hope someone learns some lessons.

Bedtime stories

Drive five miles less

How Do You Know If An Advert Is Shit?

Because the internet is a place infested by people hell-bent of opposing virtually every view they come across – see the Guardian’s Comment Is Free – or displaying ‘aggression and unkindness’ at every turn, it sometimes behoves a blogger to justify his various thoughts.

This is, generally, absurd, and it should be a given these days that anything clearly presented as a subjective opinion comes with an imaginary ‘in my opinion…’ prefix.

Getting into an argument on your own blog is rarely constructive, and generally reductive – eventually descending into nothing more than another ‘swirling online guff storm’ as Charlie Brooker has it.

‘Who are you to say whether this advert is shit?’ is a common question on AdTurds. I’m someone who has worked in the media for ten years and often writes about adverts, which is plenty qualification as far as I’m concerned – as if anyone actually needs any kind of qualification for voicing an opinion an a blog.

But there are actually all kinds of metrics out there to gauge the efficacy of an advert: sales, tracking, focus groups, polls. They’ll all be out there somewhere, hidden in the draws of some marketing agency.

More obviously Youtube and other social media are a good way to crowd source opinion, though I’d caution against placing too much stock in them, unless they’re wildly negative.

Luckily, every now and then, a bit of research from a marketing or PR outfit finds its way onto the net. I happened to stumble across a poll on Yahoo’s brand penetration following its recent Anthem advert

Unfortunately for the big Y! it revealed that awareness of Yahoo as a brand fell of a cliff following the debut of their new series of adverts and expensive relaunch.

So, if you ever wanted proof that an ad was shit, check this out.

If that’s not an AdTurd, I’d hate to see what a genuine stinker does to your brand.